Here Come the Irish

From 1718 to 1775, more than 100,000 people came from Ireland to the American colonies.  These Irish immigrants weren’t just Irish, they were mostly families that had moved from Scotland and the north of England to Ulster province in Ireland in the previous century or two.  They were Protestants who were transplanted to Ireland by the English Crown to dilute the influence of Irish Catholics, to bring English culture to Ireland and secure it as part of the British Empire.  They became known as Scotch-Irish or, more properly, Scots-Irish.

Many books have been written about the impact the Scots-Irish have had in the British Isles and in America.  Last year I read a good one called Born Fighting:  How the Scots-Irish Shaped America by Jim Webb.  He found the roots of many American characteristics in these families that were pioneers and warriors.  The book has section titles like “Rulers and Rednecks” and “The Spirit of a Revolution” and chapters like “The Radical Individualists” and “Poor but Proud–and Stubborn as Hell” and “Fight. Sing. Drink. Pray.”  It’s easy to see the American in these people.

The Scots-Irish were mostly Presbyterians, but their religious heritage became less significant when they came to America and tried to forge a life in the hills of Appalachia and the backwoods of the Carolinas.  They became known more for their rifles, their whiskey and their fierce passion for freedom.

I know of two branches of my family–the Rentfrows and the Withrows–who seem to have come from Scots-Irish stock.  Each branch produced at least one representative who clearly manifested the Scots-Irish character.

Moses Renfro (an alternate spelling of Rentfrow), my six-times-great grandfather, was born in 1728 in Virginia.  He served as a captain in the militia and fought in the wars with the Indians around the time of the Revolution.  A few years after the Revolution, Moses and a handful of family members joined Colonel John Donelson on an expedition into Tennessee.  The Donelson party traveled along the Tennessee River, down the Tennessee to the Ohio River, up the Ohio to the Cumberland River to the French Lick Salt Springs at the bluffs, the site of modern-day Nashville.  Donelson himself became one of the co-founders of the city of Nashville.

A flatboat similar to what the Donelson party would have traveled in.

In the midst of their journey, on April 12, 1780, Moses and his family left the Donelson party near where the town of Clarksburg is today and traveled along the Red River to a place where they established a frontier settlement.  Colonel Donelson noted in his journal:

“Proceeded on quietly until the 12th of April, at which time we came to the mouth of a little river running on the north side, by Moses Renfroe and his company called ‘Red River,’ up which they intended to settle.  Here they took leave of us.”

The station, or frontier settlement, established by Moses and his party was alternatively called “Red River Station” and “Renfro Station.”  Frontier stations were difficult places to live;  security and provision were constant challenges for these brave souls who pushed into new lands.  Several of the Renfro party were killed by Indians–Joseph, Peter, and Bartlett in just the first year or two.  Moses survived and eventually moved to Lincoln County, Kentucky.  Here he died at the age of 96 in 1824.

James Withrow, my seven-times-great uncle, was born in Virginia in 1746.  He served as a captain in the militia and fought against the British and Tories (Americans who were loyal to Britain) at Stono, King’s Mountain and Blackstocks in the Carolinas.  He also fought against the Cherokees.

The Battle of King’s Mountain was a pivotal moment in the southern campaign of the American Revolution.  Major Patrick Ferguson of the British 71st Regiment of Foot had raised Loyalist forces in the Carolinas and was supposed to protect the flank of the army of Cornwallis.  Ferguson issued a challenge to the rebels–the backwoodsmen of the Carolinas who supported the Revolution, many of whom were Scots-Irish.  The challenge was met and in the clash on King’s Mountain on October 20, 1780, Ferguson was killed, the Tories were defeated and Cornwallis was forced to call off his invasion of North Carolina.

Engraving depicting the death of British Major Patrick Ferguson at the Battle of Kings Mountain.

Speaking of the victory at King’s Mountain, Theodore Roosevelt wrote in his book The Winning of the West, “This brilliant victory marked the turning point of the American Revolution.”  This victory, like so many others in the American Revolution, wouldn’t have happened without the Scots-Irish.  A Hessian captain wrote in 1778, “Call this war by whatever name you may, only call it not an American rebellion;  it is nothing more or less than a Scotch Irish Presbyterian rebellion.”

Following the success of the Revolution, James Withrow served eight years in the House of Commons for the state of North Carolina.  He was also one of the three Commissioners of Confiscated (Tory) Property.  In 1789 he became County Sheriff, a position that included the onerous task of collecting taxes from independent-minded settlers.  In 1836, he died where he had long lived–in Rutherford County, North Carolina–at the age of 90.

Whether striking out as pioneers into the unsettled lands of Tennessee and Kentucky or fighting ferociously for freedom in the battles of the Revolution, the Scots-Irish undoubtedly showed their strength of character and their fierce independence.

Happy Saint Patrick’s Day!

For more on my pseudo-Irish heritage, see my earlier post, Kiss Me, I’m Irish?
For more on the Scots-Irish, see either Jim Webb’s book Born Fighting or The People With No Name by Patrick Griffin.
This entry was posted in Rentfrow family, Withrow family and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Here Come the Irish

  1. Julia says:

    Well done, Kevin! I can see some of that Scots-Irish temperament in you, no matter what Pastor “I know all about you even tho this is the first time I’ve ever spoken to you” Clapper said. And thank you for explaining the origin of the term “Scots-Irish” — never have understood that.

    • I probably do have a little of the Scots-Irish temperament, although I think I hide it well. The more I do family history, the more Scots-Irish connection I find. It sort of feels like eventually I’m going to figure out I’m 90% Scots-Irish, with a little German thrown in for good measure.

      Thanks for taking the time to read and comment.

  2. bronxboy55 says:

    Moses Renfro lived to 96, and James Withrow to 90. Have you ever done a study of how long your ancestors lived? We always hear that the average lifespan in previous centuries was so much shorter than it is today, yet many people seemed to have lived well into their 80s and 90s. I wonder if the higher infant mortality rate back then brought down the average lifespan, statistically.

    Great job, Kevin, as always.

    • I’m no expert on statistics, but I’ll bet there’s always outliers…people who beat the odds. Maybe I just happen to descend from a bunch of them. But I can also tell you that for every 96-year-old in my family tree, I have a 52-year-old (my grandfather) or a 57-year-old (my great grandfather) or a 33-year-old (my 5-times-great grandfather).

      Thanks for your thoughtful comment. One day I’ll do that study of how long my ancestors lived…

  3. pokedpotato says:

    That’s cute that you & Julia comment on each other’s blogs. Do you talk about them at home or not?? All I get out of Zach was, “I liked your last blog” or “It was okay”.

    (You can tell it is late when my comments are totally non-blog related but instead random ramblings…I did think the clover picture was funny. I’m not sure why.)

    • We talk some. But I think I like to talk about it more than she does. She writes for a living, as a trained professional. I just write for fun. But I do like to talk to her about strengths/weaknesses, things that could make my writing better, etc., when she’ll indulge me.

      The clover picture was funny…a break from my typical choices, I thought.

      • pokedpotato says:

        That is nice. I am positive that Zach is critical of my writing sometimes, but he always refuses to divulge his mind if he thinks I could possibly be offended. I wish he would because I always want to learn how to make my writing better.

  4. Kate Mulvey says:

    My husband stumbled upon your blog and sent me a link. I found it extremely interesting, because Moses Renfro is also my Great Grandfather x7! So, we must be related, but I don’t think we’ve ever met. I’d love to hear more from you about the family history. I only last year learned of the family link to Nashville when I discovered one of Moses’s brother’s name on the city plaque. Wonderful writing. Truly enjoyed it!
    Kate Mulvey

    • ArborFam says:

      Thank you! I’d be happy to talk more about the Withrows and share what I know. Unfortunately, I haven’t done a lot of research on the Withrows yet, so most of what I have is from other people. I will be doing some original research soon and will be happy to share. If you’re interested in hearing more, you can email me at Thanks for reading!

  5. Robin Withrow says:

    LOL. And James Withrow is MY 5 times great grandfather. Nice to meet you cuz!

    Robin Withrow

  6. Gina says:

    Hi. Is this blog still active? I am related to the Withrows, and I’m just beginning my search.

    • ArborFam says:

      The blog is still active, but I haven’t been writing as much recently on it because I’m doing more research and writing on another project offline. I’d be happy to share what I have about the Withrows, but I haven’t done a lot of original work on them yet. Most of what I have is from other people. I will be doing more work on the Withrows soon for my other offline project. Feel free to email me at for more info. Thanks for reading!

    • Robin Withrow says:

      I have a good bit of Withrow research , too. Would be happy to share. My tree is on Ancestry “Withrow Family” username rwmercer1. The above Cptn. James Withrow was my 6 times great grandfather.

      • Gina says:

        Thanks Robin…my tree is there too “Families Are Forever…” I’ll send you an invite. I’ve sent Kevin one just now. You know, I really appreciate ya’ll sharing your info on our families. The info I have is from my own research and other trees on ancestry and thru the DNA thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s